How Much Gospel Is Too Much?

Thursday, June 3rd, 2010

DespairMen who thought the best of Dr. Norman Nagel reported how he used to interview new professorial candidates and ask them this question: “If you were to be accused of any heresy, which one would you choose?”

Now, think about that for a moment. Which one would you choose if you were asked such a thing?

The answer he was looking for was ‘antinomianism.’ Why? Because if someone gave that answer, they probably ‘got’ the Gospel.

Now that Dr. Rosenbladt’s presentation “The Gospel For Those Broken By The Church” is now available for free, we’re beginning to get the expected concerns regarding antinomianism. Dr. Rosenbladt is simply being ‘too free’ with the grace, isn’t he?

But think about this for a moment: In our daily lives—at the office, with our spouses, with our children and friends and extended family, with acquaintances or business contacts, even people we meet as we do daily mundane things like running errands, and sadly, even in church—how often do we receive, or expect to receive, any level of grace whatsoever?

In this world, we are simply immersed in law—of all kinds, God’s law as well as civic. And we’re used to it. A little too used to it. We’re used to being fenced in. But on those (tragically rare) occasions when someone finally preaches the Gospel in all its sweetness—”200-proof” as Dr. Rosenbladt calls it—those fences are taken away. The law was completely fulfilled in Christ.

And pouring with a liberal wrist like that typically causes one of two reactions. One kind of person—in our experience, modern-day Pharisees—quickly reacts to this kind of talk with comments like, “Well, you can’t tell people that they’re that free, because they’ll run afoul of it as St. Paul puts in the mouths of his accusers in Romans 6, sinning more in order that grace may abound more! They have to be reined in somehow! You have to bring those fences in a bit to corral the freedom so that their sin doesn’t run amok, even more than before.”

The other kind of person comes from a completely different point of view, that of the “bruised reed” and “smoldering wick”. These are the people with whom we engage regularly. And I will tell you right now that the modern-day Pharisees of whom I just spoke almost never comprehend these bruised reeds and smoldering wicks. The bruised reeds and smoldering wicks have been deeply hurt, spiritually and emotionally, and they’re running very low on hope, on the edge of rejecting Jesus entirely because they just can’t measure up to the requirements set before them. There are more people out there like this than people can imagine. They’re suffering greatly under errant and false teachings. And it is primarily for these people that Dr. Rosenbladt wrote and presented “The Gospel For Those Broken By The Church.”

Here’s an interesting question: To those who are worried that teachers like Dr. Rosenbladt may be offering the grace of the Gospel too freely I would ask when was the last time you got up out of your chair and actually spoke to the average guy or gal on the street? When was the last time you had a discussion with someone who was struggling with their lack of “good works” and self-focused (and false) teachings they’ve been receiving and which are driving them to despair? What would your counsel to them be, exactly?

I’ll tell you what I usually hear from these Pharisees. Their response often starts well—that Jesus Christ died for their sins on the cross and was raised from the dead in order that they, too, may have eternal life with Him. But then there’s a follow-through. They can’t leave it there. Their next step is making sure that the hearer knows that from his or her faith that he or she must/should/will produce good works.

The problem lies here not in the statement itself, but in how it is being taught to be applied by the listener. For the correct answer to this, I would simply ask, “Who gets the credit for one’s faith in Christ, according to Scripture?” (“…and no one can say, ‘Jesus is Lord,’ except by the Holy Spirit.” 1 Cor 12:3) The One who bears the burden of bringing a person to faith is the same One who bears the burden of following through with the good works borne of that faith.

And to those who will say that I am arguing that antinomianism doesn’t exist, or that Christians aren’t bound by God’s law and can willfully sin even more in their faith to receive more grace, or that we don’t need to hear the law preached to us, I say now that the law is good and must be taught and preached, and you do not understand to whom or about what I’m writing. Refer back to my comment about getting out there and talking to people on the street. As Dr. Rosenbladt says, the people who particularly need to hear this message “…need more law like they need a hole in the head.” Heaping more law on top of the mountain of law they’ve already received may very well break the camel’s back and drive him or her out of the faith entirely.

The broken yet faithful believers in Christ find themselves in the same position as St. Paul himself: “For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing.” (Rom 7:19 – ESV) St. Paul understood that this struggle was the very nature of what it is to be a Christian.

But the bruised reeds and smoldering wicks are not being taught that the Gospel is exactly what should be their comfort in their affliction. They are instead told to “work harder”, “pray harder”, “have more faith” or any other number of hideous teachings, driven by the terrible fear that their faith and eternal salvation is “on the line.” They aren’t hearing that, even in their Christian faith, Christ died for them and their sins. And not just the sins which they committed before they were Christians, but all of them, even the ones which occur in their faith—even the ones they committed on purpose, knowing they were sinning the whole time!

This Gospel of which I speak is what is too often missing in most churches today. But the Gospel is the good news.

Are you torn asunder by the fact that you continue to sin while still believing in Jesus Christ? Did you know that you are lumped in with the saints in that struggle? That struggle between your fallen flesh and your faith in Jesus is the nature of being a Christian! But who is saying that these days? Very few.

So Dr. Rosenbladt puts this presentation out there to those who are not hearing the good news that Christ died on the cross even for sinful Christians like them. Controversial? You bet. But it is the truth. If you aren’t hearing this message anywhere else, please make sure you download Dr. Rosenbladt’s presentation for free. Listen to it or read it over and over. Let it sink in slowly. Like sitting in a nice jacuzzi, let it seep into your pores. Enjoy the comfort of the Gospel in all its sweetness. You’ve been fed nothing but law, law, law for so long and your despair and fear are great. You need to marinate in the Gospel for a long time now. Enjoy it like the finest wine. Breathe it in like the best incense. Let it permeate your muscles, down to your bones.

To you bruised reeds and smoldering wicks (and all those Dr. Rosenbladt calls “those broken by the church”) I say this is most certainly true: Christ died for you. And the Spirit will continue the good work He started in blessing you with faith in Jesus. Good works will be and are borne of your faith—whether you are conscious of them at the time or not. (And I suspect that most often, we are not aware of our good works when they happen—“Then the righteous will answer him, ‘Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you something to drink? When did we see you a stranger and invite you in, or needing clothes and clothe you? When did we see you sick or in prison and go to visit you?’ Matt 25:37-39) Christ died for sinners. If you are a sinner, you qualify—regardless of whether you’re already a Christian believer or not. Even while you sin in your faith, Christ died for you, and through faith His perfect works are imputed to you as 100% gift.

But don’t take it from me. Dr. Rosenbladt is the maestro to whom I always defer. Let him speak these words of comfort and assurance to you himself. Download “The Gospel For Those Broken By The Church” for free right now.

By Ted R

5 Comments

  1. Aaron says:

    If every Christian pastor were courageous enough to declare the Gospel with such boldness that we would all be called antinomian.

    I have loved this lecture for so long, and I am so thankful that you have made it free so that I can freely share it with people I know who really need to hear the beauty of the Gospel.

    Grace and peace to you!

  2. [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by New Reformation Pres, Aaron Gardner. Aaron Gardner said: How Much Gospel Is Too Much? http://bit.ly/b1XZMe [...]

  3. Larry says:

    That is a GOOD interview question. My best Christian friend and I use to ponder this a lot during our lunch talks. We both concurred, “I’d rather err on the side of the Gospel too much than vice versa”. Dr. Loyd Jones once said, and I’m paraphrasing from memory the quote, “If you’ve never been accused of antinomianism like Paul was in Romans, you’ve likely never given the Gospel”. Hard but powerful words.

    And you’ve nailed it, everything else in this earthly life screams merit and reward for this or that effort. It’s the underlying “lingo”, if you will, of everything we do and its exhausting (and that’s coming from someone who would be classified as a workaholic and not a slacker, my wife would confirm this). Yet it is utterly exhausting. The ONLY message in the ENTIRE world that sounds different is “Christ did this for me”.

    As a similar note my same buddy and I in our more reformed days use to get bent around the axle as to how to “offer the gospel to someone”. Because you always wanted to, as he put it, “somehow close the deal”, i.e. know they did something to “accept it” and thus “be saved”. So you’d loose how to simply give the real gospel to anyone in a morass of hoops to jump through and offer for salvation (though you didn’t formerly mean them to be “works”). Then finally it donned on us one day, we asked ourselves, “Can you ever feel comfortable and not in danger of denying the real faith by saying, not to a general unknown person, but a particular person right in front of you, ‘Bob Christ didn’t die for you unless you do (fill in the blank, up to and including faith itself)’”.

    But my own literal in a flash of the eye conversion from agnostic/atheist to Christian was based not really upon the Law but on a pure proclamation of Christ and Him crucified for me. That’s what broke me literally in a single moment when He cried out, “My God, My God why hast thou forsaken me”, drinking the dregs of wrath to the bitter last drop for me. It stunned me for the first time something like this, “So THAT is what God is like”. It was literally waking up to a reality that you never saw before and realizing the reality/paradigm you were living under was false.

    When I talk to ex-RC, ex-baptist, ex-whatevers who once were in the church but left and are now somewhere between agnostic atheist they are always stunned to hear that Christ was actually crucified for the forgiveness of sin, for them, and that THAT is the Christian faith as opposed to some form of “progress” morally or otherwise. They may not suddenly “become Christians” or “return” to the church they grew up in, but it’s a stunning news they’ve not heard before.

    • Ted R says:

      Larry, thanks very much for your comment. Your story is pretty close to others I’ve been hearing here recently.

      I now think there are more people out there suffering under the damage of Gospel-less teachings than we can imagine, many still attending church and many not. The people for whom Dr. Rosenbladt wrote his presentation have consistently come away after listening to it in pure amazement. I can’t tell you how often I’ve been hearing, “Well, if church had been more like that, I would probably have stayed.” And that’s exactly the point.

      Too often these people don’t say anything to anyone, or maybe only say something to their close friends which even then belies the true depth of their despair. They sit in church dutifully and say nothing. Or they finally stop attending, and still say nothing. They don’t know what to say or to whom they should go, or they’ve simply given up as failures.

      So we’re just going to keep banging the drum and trying to help get the sound of the Gospel in people’s ears. This is why we’re so happy to finally be able to offer this presentation for free and why we’re asking everyone to help share it everywhere and in any way they can think of.

      You know, burn the MP3 to CDs and hand them out! The need is great. These people need the salve of the healing Gospel as soon as possible.

  4. J. Dean says:

    An excellent and well-written blog, Ted. Thank you. You’ve almost persuaded me to change to Lutheranism!

Leave a Reply