Preachers of Doubt and Preachers of Faith
Monday, September 26th, 2011
Last week Dr. Gene Veith over on the Cranach blog put up a brilliant post contrasting preachers who preach to build us up in the faith and those who see it as their job to sow doubt in your relationship to God and undercut our assurance.
He writes,
“I have noticed that there are two kinds of preachers, especially when addressing young people: One kind tries to assure the listeners of their salvation in Christ, underscoring His grace and mercy and His atoning work on the Cross. The other kind tries to make the listeners question whether they are “really” Christians. (“Did you REALLY give your life to the Lord? Do you show the fruit of true faith? Does your life show evidence of true conversion? Maybe you need to commit your life to him again, just to be sure.”)
Granted the problem of nominal Christianity. And granted the need to make people realize how sinful they are so as to help them grasp their need of the Gospel. But I would argue that the latter approach can do great harm. The one thing that DOES make a Christian is faith in Christ. Doubt is the opposite of faith. To make a person doubt his or her salvation is, ironically, to destroy faith, rather than to build it up. Furthermore, these “are you really a Christian” messages have the effect of making the hearers look within, at their good works or their feelings or their piety or whatever.”
(Read the rest of the post here.)
We have seen much of this. In some circles it is the mark of a successful preacher if he can ‘pack the altars’ of a church on a weekly basis, or in the case of a guest preacher, on the occasion of his visit. In contrast, a good preacher of the law and the Gospel will be used by the Holy Spirit to ‘afflict the comfortable, and comfort the afflicted,’ and do so in right measure.
Undercutting the believer’s assurance is, I suspect, the mechanism that drives the big evangelistic crusades like Harvest. In reality, how many unbelievers really go to evangelistic crusades? Surely some do, but when I was a rank unbeliever, I would not purposefully go to a venue for which the sole purpose was converting people like me. (It is like inviting a bass to a bass fishing tournament. There is a serious disconnect.) I would like to see some figures on how many people going forward to pray in these things are ‘re-dedicating’ their lives.
I was driven from the church by a constant diet of sermons that always called into question my faith, commitment, sincerity, etc. Those kind of sermons are also the easiest ones to preach, because it is easy to manipulate people with a wrong use of the law. Anyone can tear down, but few are able to build up. I know many people who have left the faith after years of this crushed any hope they had.
If you find yourself in a similar situation, flee before it does irreparable harm to your faith. Find a church that preaches and teaches the grace of God in Christ and makes it a central theme, not just pays lip service to it. Listen to the sermons. Is the pastor building up the congregation in their faith, or is he undermining their faith week after week?
If you are unclear about how this sounds, any of the sermons off of these sites will give outstanding examples of solid Law/Gospel preaching that will build up your faith.
http://www.htlcms.org/sermons/P10/
http://www.faithcapo.org/connect/sermons.htm
http://www.firstluth.com/?page_id=35l
If you found the above post or the links valuable, please feel free to share with your friends and family via one of the buttons below.
By Pat K

We have had a steady and constantly growing stream of new followers on Twitter and and new Facebook friends. We appreciate the time and attention given to us by those of you who have linked to us through various social media in the last several months, and would also like to thank our faithful supporters who have been with us for awhile.

I recently came across a couple of posts on

